The efficiency of surplus sharing in sequential labor and goods markets, 2018 meeting papers 622, society for economic dynamics. Does housing wealth contribute to wealth inequality. We were the first to reflect in depth on pikettys book and on the share of capital represented by housing. Its aim integrates the debate theories of growth, income distribution, inequality and. The following are minisummaries of some of the main criticisms of pikettys capital in the 21st century that relate to his descriptions of the historical changes in inequality and their current trends. Gwen ifill gets debate on his data and conclusions from. Odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle and etienne wasmer. A comment on thomas pikettys capital in the 21st century. Thomas pikettys claim that the ratio of capital to national income is approaching 19thcentury levels has fuelled the debate over inequality.
Odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume camille chapelle, etienne wasmer 30 june 2014 thomas pikettys claim that the ratio of capital to national income is approaching 19thcentury levels has fuelled the debate over inequality. Etienne wasmer 2014 attempt to show that the books conclusions. He believes it takes precedence over other economic concerns like poverty, unemployment, or slow economic growth. Debating pikettys theory on how wealth begets wealth, widens. Also since the inequality share of income measures are based on marginal product there is an inconsistency between how piketty measures aggregates.
This work is a development of the may 14, 2014 discussion paper. In his book, capital in the 21st century,thomas piketty highlights the risk of an explosion of wealth inequality because. His claim that capital is back, because the ratio of capital over income is returning to the levels of the end of the 19th century, is probably one of the most striking conclusions of his 700 pages. Thomas pikettys capital in the 21st century has been the most important book economy in recent times. When it was first published in english in the spring of 2014, thomas pikettys book capital in the twentyfirst century was a surprising bestseller. First, the authors result is based on the rise of only. I noticed the key role of housing capital in the u shape of the capitallabor ratio and elaborated on it during my. In capital, french economist thomas piketty explores how wealth and the income derived from it magnifies the problems of inequality. Repenser leconomie yann algan, philippe askenazy, pierre cahuc, esther duflo, thomas philippon, thomas piketty, david thesmar, etienne wasmer on. A guide to why r is greater than g jump to media player aiming to explain why r is greater than g in french philosopher thomas pikettys capital in the 21st century book.
The return of the bestselling, awardwinning economist extraordinaire with the same powerful evidence, and range of reference, as his global bestseller capital in the twentyfirst century and in columns of 700 words, rather than 700 pages chronicles sets out thomas pikettys analysis of the financial crisis, what has happened since and where we should go from. The way europe behaved in the crisis was nothing short of disastrous. This work is based on a discussion by etienne wasmer on capital in the 21st. They point out what they see as an inconsistency in the thesis. The agenda for economics and inequality, which is sure to spark much debate in its own right. Jan 15, 2015 par guillaume allegre and xavier timbeau in a response to capital in the twentyfirst century, odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle and etienne wasmer 2014 attempt to show that the conclusion of the book in terms of the explosion of wealth inequality is not plausible. Many on the left see the popularity of thomas pikettys new book, capital in the twentyfirst century, as a. Thomas pikettys new war and peacesized book published on thursday. An internationally recognized center for advanced studies and a national model for public doctoral education, the graduate center offers more than thirty.
This is the fifth of five posts on capital in the 21st century. Books by thomas piketty author of capital in the twenty. In a response to capital in the twentyfirst century, odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle and etienne wasmer 2014 attempt to show that the books conclusions regarding an explosion in wealth inequality are not plausible. Pikettys basic tax would depress the capital stock by. Summers writes, once in a great while, a heavy academic tome dominates for a time the policy debate and, despite bristling with footnotes, shows up on the bestseller list. For a book that contains mathematical equations, it saw unthinkable sales, clearly resonating with readers and eventually even the political system, as it provided a respectable background to mounting dissatisfaction with the economic status quo. In his bestselling book, capital in the 21st century, piketty 2014 attributes this stylised fact to the decline in gdp growth rates and the longrun stability of the saving rates see also piketty and saez 2014, piketty and zucman 2014.
Etienne wasmer born 1970 is a french professor and economist. I was asked to discuss the french edition in december 20 le capital au xxie siecle, a few weeks before the english edition was released, at a conference in sciences po organized by the maxpo center. French economists capital and ideology expands on themes in capital in the 21st century, which sold 2m copies. Some of the success of the book comes from the fact that there is concern with rising inequality. The prices of houses have tripled in france from the 1990s to the present day, but this does not mean that the gap between the rich and the. The authors point out an inconsistency in thomas pikettys thesis. Debating pikettys theory on how wealth begets wealth. This work is based on a discussion by etienne wasmer on capital. The impact of pikettys wealth tax on the poor, the rich, and the middle class pdf executive summary in his bestseller capital in the twentyfirst century, thomas piketty recommends a wealth tax as a remedy to inequality. This is no surprise to those of us who have been chronicling the loss of destruction of middle income housing affordability where urban containment policy has been implemented from australia to canada, ireland, new zealand, the united kingdom and the united states.
Doesnt real estate capital really contribute to inequality. Repenser leconomie francois geerolf, gabriel zucman, esther duflo, xavier gabaix, pierreolivier gourinchas, thomas philippon, thomas piketty, emmanuel saez, david thesmar, etienne wasmer on. The basic version of pikettys wealth tax would impose a tax rate of. This work is based on a discussion by etienne wasmer on capital in the 21st century at sciences po held on dec. In the economics of inequality, piketty boils down the data to about 140 pages plus endnotes, and explains the causes of economic. Piketty and wealth inequality conversable economist. Why are economists giving piketty the cold shoulder. In a response to capital in the twentyfirst century, odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle and etienne wasmer 2014 attempt to show that the conclusion of the book in terms of the explosion of wealth inequality is not plausible. Etienne wasmer 2012 price, wage and employment adjustments in 20072008 and some inference for the current european crisis.
In his book, capital in the 21st century,thomas piketty highlights the risk of an explosion of wealth inequality because capital. Last week, tyler cowen and i had a piece over at the upshot looking at some of the reasons why french economist thomas pikettys book, capital in the twentyfirst century, didnt get the same. O capital no seculo xxi wikipedia, a enciclopedia livre. Oct 06, 2015 piketty s other books tend to run 500 pages or more 700 pages for capital in the 21st century, tomes that require a significant time commitment to get through. In his book, capital in the 21st century,thomas piketty highlights the risk of an explosion of wealth inequality. In his book, capital in the 21st century,thomas piketty highlights the risk of an. Wasmer mainly focuses on the fields of labor economics, job search theory, discrimination and human capital. Apr 09, 2018 thomas piketty argues that education is a big equaliser in a highly unequal society like south africa. For a book that contains mathematical equations, it saw unthinkable sales, clearly resonating. The impressive success of thomas pikettys book piketty 2014 shows that inequality is a great concern in most countries. He obtained an engineer degree from ecole polytechnique in france, a master from delta departement et laboratoire deconomie theorique et appliquee, at the ecole des hautes etudes en sciences sociales and a phd in economics at the london school of economics and political science. Our work challenges the conclusions of the author in three steps.
Dec 12, 20 extended discussion paper by bonnet odran. Among the criticisms this leads to are that piketty measures aggregate wealth by asset value as his numbers are susceptible to house price movements hence bbcw and rognlie criticisms below. Housing capital and pikettys analysis vox, cepr policy portal. The impressive success of thomas pikettys book piketty 2014 shows. Pierre henri bono, guillaume chapelle, and etienne wasmer 2014. The impact of pikettys wealth tax on the poor, the rich, and the. A comment on thomas pikettys capital in the 21st century, sciences po economics discussion papers 201407, sciences po departement of economics. No 201407, sciences po publications from sciences po abstract. In his book, capital in the 21st century,thomas piketty highlights the risk of an explosion of wealth inequality because capital is accumulating faster than income in several countries including the us and european countries such as france. Contributors join in a conversation to celebrate its release and discuss how lessons from piketty can help us understand the current economic and political moment. Opinion thomas piketty and his critics the new york times. Apr 28, 2014 thomas pikettys new war and peacesized book published on thursday. In his influential book, capital in the twentyfirst century,1 piketty argues that. The graduate center, the city university of new york established in 1961, the graduate center of the city university of new york cuny is devoted primarily to doctoral studies and awards most of cunys doctoral degrees.
Rising house prices may be chiefly responsible for rising inequality. Housing capital and pikettys analysis vox, cepr policy. Its aim integrates the debate theories of growth, income distribution, inequality and differences between the extremes income and income of the majority. Spa pt a wealth tax in the united states would reduce investment, wages, employment, incomes, and output. Many on the left see the popularity of thomas pikettys new book, capital in the twentyfirst century, as a sign of hope. By odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle and etienne wasmer.
Pierre henri bono, guillaume camille chapelle, etienne wasmer 30. This work is a development of the may 14, 2014 discussion. Thomas piketty argues that education is a big equaliser in a highly unequal society like south africa. Etienne wasmer argues that esssentially all of the recent variation in. The work predicts a slow increase in the share of capital income and inequality. Flinn, journal of economic literature, volume 51, number 2, june 20, pp. The efficiency of surplus sharing in sequential labor and goods markets, 2018 meeting papers. One economist said your book was taking off because people no longer believed. Five years ago, the united states and europe had approximately the same unemployment rate and level of public debt.
He is a professor directeur detudes at the school for advanced studies in the social sciences ehess, associate chair at the paris school of economics and centennial professor at the international inequalities institute, which is part of the london school. Etienne wasmer is a professor of economics in the social science division at nyuad. In a response to capital in the twentyfirst century, odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle and etienne wasmer 2014 attempt to show that the book s conclusions regarding an explosion in wealth inequality are not plausible. Thomas pikettys capital in the twentyfirst century is such a volume. Jun 30, 2014 the impressive success of thomas pikettys book piketty 2014 shows that inequality is a great concern in most countries. Odran bonnet, pierrehenri bono, guillaume chapelle et etienne wasmer, housing equity does contribute to inequality. Thomas piketty has 50 books on goodreads with 116989 ratings. Unemployment has exploded here in europe, while it has declined in the united states. This is no surprise to those of us who have been chronicling the loss of destruction of middle income housing affordability where urban containment policy has been implemented from australia to canada, ireland, new zealand, the united kingdom and the. Some blogs or news paper articles pointing to our work non exhaustive list april 2015. Piketty follows up capital in the twentyfirst century, last years landmark economic analysis, with a slightly revised version of a book he wrote in 1997. Rognlie suggests that a better title for pikettys book would have been. These questions and more are tackled in the new book after piketty.
In the economics of inequality, piketty boils down the data to about 140 pages plus endnotes, and explains the causes of economic inequality. Pdf in his book, capital in the 21st century, thomas piketty. The impact of pikettys wealth tax on the poor, the rich. Thomas pikettys most popular book is capital in the twentyfirst century. Efficiency in sequential labor and goods markets, working paper series 2018, federal reserve bank of san francisco, revised 27 sep 2018. This column argues that pikettys claim rests on the recent increase in the price of housing. A comment on thomas pikettys capital in the 21st century, sciences po economics discussion papers, 2014.
815 808 94 635 226 1171 671 1346 505 1181 496 1018 1061 149 1017 252 659 1396 750 47 1308 693 671 662 503 1187 1171 1258 861 1483 1365 1226 1353 901 911 325 45 122 834